Club CarOnward Lifted 4 PassengervsICONi40L
Complete head-to-head comparison. Which model is right for you?
Overall Winner: ICON i40L
The ICON i40L wins with its higher top speed (25 mph), modern tech including a 10.1-inch touchscreen, four-wheel disc brakes, and comprehensive standard features. The Club Car Onward Lifted 4P fights back with a lower price and the legendary AlumiCore aluminum frame.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | Club Car Onward Lifted 4 Passenger | ICON i40L | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance | 7/10 The i40L's 25 mph top speed and 5kW motor significantly outperform the Onward Lifted's 19 mph. | 9/10 The ICON also delivers 40+ miles of confirmed range on its lithium system. | ICON i40L |
| Build Quality | 9/10 Club Car's AlumiCore aluminum frame is the gold standard for durability — rust-proof and proven over decades. | 7/10 ICON's injection-molded body is resilient but newer to the market. | Club Car Onward Lifted 4 Passenger |
| Comfort & Features | 7/10 The i40L comes loaded: 10. | 9/10 1-inch touchscreen, Bluetooth, backup camera, seat belts, lit side mirrors with turn signals, and hazard lights — all standard. The Onward Lifted requires add-ons for comparable features. | ICON i40L |
| Value for Money | 7/10 Despite costing $2,350 more, the i40L includes so many standard features that would be costly add-ons on the Onward that it arguably offers better overall value. | 8/10 Despite costing $2,350 more, the i40L includes so many standard features that would be costly add-ons on the Onward that it arguably offers better overall value. | ICON i40L |
| Technology | 6/10 The i40L's 10. | 9/10 1-inch IP67-rated touchscreen with phone integration, backup camera, and comprehensive digital display is far ahead of the Onward's more traditional setup. | ICON i40L |
| Safety | 7/10 The i40L features four-wheel disc brakes, electromagnetic parking brake, seat belts, reverse buzzer, and comprehensive lighting — a class-leading safety package. | 9/10 The i40L features four-wheel disc brakes, electromagnetic parking brake, seat belts, reverse buzzer, and comprehensive lighting — a class-leading safety package. | ICON i40L |
| Off-Road Capability | 8/10 Both are purpose-built lifted carts with enhanced ground clearance and all-terrain tires. | 8/10 The Onward's aluminum frame handles rough conditions well, while the i40L's powerful motor tackles hills with ease. | Tie |
Performance
ICON i40LThe i40L's 25 mph top speed and 5kW motor significantly outperform the Onward Lifted's 19 mph.
The ICON also delivers 40+ miles of confirmed range on its lithium system.
Build Quality
Club Car Onward Lifted 4 PassengerClub Car's AlumiCore aluminum frame is the gold standard for durability — rust-proof and proven over decades.
ICON's injection-molded body is resilient but newer to the market.
Comfort & Features
ICON i40LThe i40L comes loaded: 10.
1-inch touchscreen, Bluetooth, backup camera, seat belts, lit side mirrors with turn signals, and hazard lights — all standard. The Onward Lifted requires add-ons for comparable features.
Value for Money
ICON i40LDespite costing $2,350 more, the i40L includes so many standard features that would be costly add-ons on the Onward that it arguably offers better overall value.
Despite costing $2,350 more, the i40L includes so many standard features that would be costly add-ons on the Onward that it arguably offers better overall value.
Technology
ICON i40LThe i40L's 10.
1-inch IP67-rated touchscreen with phone integration, backup camera, and comprehensive digital display is far ahead of the Onward's more traditional setup.
Safety
ICON i40LThe i40L features four-wheel disc brakes, electromagnetic parking brake, seat belts, reverse buzzer, and comprehensive lighting — a class-leading safety package.
The i40L features four-wheel disc brakes, electromagnetic parking brake, seat belts, reverse buzzer, and comprehensive lighting — a class-leading safety package.
Off-Road Capability
TieBoth are purpose-built lifted carts with enhanced ground clearance and all-terrain tires.
The Onward's aluminum frame handles rough conditions well, while the i40L's powerful motor tackles hills with ease.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
Onward Lifted 4 Passenger
Choose if you...
- 1You trust Club Car's decades of proven AlumiCore durability
- 2A lower starting price is important
- 3You want gas powertrain flexibility
- 4Brand heritage and dealer network matter to you
i40L
Choose if you...
- 1Higher top speed (25 mph) and range (40+ miles) are priorities
- 2You want a modern touchscreen and backup camera included
- 3Four-wheel disc brakes and comprehensive safety features matter
- 4You prefer an all-inclusive package without costly add-ons
Similar Models to Consider
Other models from each brand that might fit your needs
Related Comparisons
Explore more comparisons between these brands and models
Onward Lifted 4 Passenger vs i40L FAQs
Common questions about these two models
Why is the ICON i40L $2,350 more than the Club Car Onward Lifted?
Which lifted cart is better for off-road use?
Is the Club Car brand name worth paying for?
Related Guides
Must-Have Accessories for Your New Golf Cart
Top-rated accessories that golf cart owners buy first. Prices checked March 2026.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This helps support our free resources.
