Club CarvsICON EV
Complete comparison of two popular golf cart brands. Which is right for you?
Overall Winner: Club Car
Club Car wins for buyers prioritizing long-term durability, resale value, and rust-proof construction. ICON EV wins for buyers who want more features at a lower price point. The $2,000-4,000 price difference is significant, but Club Car's aluminum frame provides decades of worry-free ownership.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | Club Car | ICON EV | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Build Quality & Frame | 10/10 Aircraft-grade aluminum AlumiCore™ frame. Completely rust-proof, lighter weight, and will last 20+ years without structural concerns. | 7/10 Powder-coated steel frame with limited warranty. Good quality for the price but can rust over time in humid climates. | Club Car |
| Price & Value | 6/10 Premium pricing starting at $9,475. You're paying for the aluminum frame, brand reputation, and dealer network. | 9/10 Excellent value starting at $8,995 with more standard features. Street-legal ready with 10-year lithium warranty. | ICON EV |
| Battery & Warranty | 7/10 6-year lithium battery warranty. 2-year vehicle warranty. Solid but not industry-leading. | 9/10 10-year ECO Lithium warranty (industry-leading). 3-year vehicle warranty. Outstanding coverage. | ICON EV |
| Features & Technology | 7/10 Monsoon Canopy, LED lighting, three drive modes on HP models. Quality features but fewer standard inclusions. | 9/10 7-inch digital display, Bluetooth audio, USB charging, LED lighting all standard. All models street-legal ready. | ICON EV |
| Resale Value | 10/10 Industry-leading resale value. Well-maintained Club Cars hold value for decades. Aluminum frame ensures structural integrity. | 6/10 Good resale for a newer brand but lacks the track record. Steel frame condition affects long-term value. | Club Car |
| Dealer Network | 10/10 Extensive nationwide dealer network established over 65+ years. Easy to find service anywhere. | 7/10 Growing dealer network, strong in Florida and Texas. Still expanding national coverage. | Club Car |
| Performance | 9/10 Superior hill-climbing due to lighter aluminum frame. Excellent power-to-weight ratio and speed control. | 8/10 Good performance with street-legal 25 mph speed. Handles well on flat terrain. | Club Car |
Build Quality & Frame
Club CarAircraft-grade aluminum AlumiCore™ frame. Completely rust-proof, lighter weight, and will last 20+ years without structural concerns.
Powder-coated steel frame with limited warranty. Good quality for the price but can rust over time in humid climates.
Price & Value
ICON EVPremium pricing starting at $9,475. You're paying for the aluminum frame, brand reputation, and dealer network.
Excellent value starting at $8,995 with more standard features. Street-legal ready with 10-year lithium warranty.
Battery & Warranty
ICON EV6-year lithium battery warranty. 2-year vehicle warranty. Solid but not industry-leading.
10-year ECO Lithium warranty (industry-leading). 3-year vehicle warranty. Outstanding coverage.
Features & Technology
ICON EVMonsoon Canopy, LED lighting, three drive modes on HP models. Quality features but fewer standard inclusions.
7-inch digital display, Bluetooth audio, USB charging, LED lighting all standard. All models street-legal ready.
Resale Value
Club CarIndustry-leading resale value. Well-maintained Club Cars hold value for decades. Aluminum frame ensures structural integrity.
Good resale for a newer brand but lacks the track record. Steel frame condition affects long-term value.
Dealer Network
Club CarExtensive nationwide dealer network established over 65+ years. Easy to find service anywhere.
Growing dealer network, strong in Florida and Texas. Still expanding national coverage.
Performance
Club CarSuperior hill-climbing due to lighter aluminum frame. Excellent power-to-weight ratio and speed control.
Good performance with street-legal 25 mph speed. Handles well on flat terrain.
Popular Model Comparisons
Head-to-head matchups of similar models
Club Car Onward 4 Passenger
$10,722
ICON i40
$8,995
Club Car costs $1,700 more but has aluminum frame; ICON has longer warranties and more features.
Club Car Onward HP Li-Ion
$13,120
ICON i40L (Lifted)
$10,995
ICON is $2,100 cheaper with longer battery warranty and lifted suspension.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
ICON EV
Best for: Best lithium warranty & variety
Choose if you...
- 1Budget is a primary consideration
- 2You want the longest lithium warranty (10 years)
- 3More standard features matter to you
- 4You need street-legal ready out of the box
- 5You live in a dry climate (less rust concern)
Club Car
Best for: Long-term value & durability
Choose if you...
- 1You live in a coastal, humid, or snowy climate
- 2Long-term resale value is a priority
- 3You want the peace of mind of an aluminum frame
- 4You need extensive dealer/service network access
- 5You're buying for 15+ years of use
Other Brand Comparisons
Explore more head-to-head matchups
Club Car vs E-Z-GO
Aluminum vs steel frame comparison
Yamaha vs Club Car
Warranty vs resale value comparison
Yamaha vs E-Z-GO
Warranty vs budget comparison
ICON EV vs Evolution
Head-to-head brand comparison
E-Z-GO vs Evolution
Head-to-head brand comparison
Denago vs ICON EV
Head-to-head brand comparison
Best Golf Cart Brands
See all 10 top-ranked brands
Club Car vs ICON EV FAQs
Common questions about these two brands
Is Club Car worth the extra money over ICON?
Which brand is more reliable?
Which has better warranty coverage?
Can ICON compete with Club Car quality?
Which is better for street-legal use?
Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?
Get free quotes from local Club Car and ICON EV dealers near you.
Stay Updated with Golf Cart News
Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.