Club CarOnward HP LithiumvsEvolutionForester 4 Plus
Complete head-to-head comparison. Which model is right for you?
Overall Winner: Tie
Both are lifted 4-passenger lithium carts, but the price gap tells the story. The Club Car Onward HP Lithium brings the industry's best aluminum frame, unmatched customization options, and the strongest resale value in the business — but at a significant premium. The Evolution Forester 4 Plus at $6,995 offers 25 mph speed, modern features, and capable off-road performance at a fraction of the cost. Budget buyers save thousands with the Evolution; legacy buyers invest in Club Car's proven longevity.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | Club Car Onward HP Lithium | Evolution Forester 4 Plus | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance & Power | 7/10 Lithium-ion power with consistent performance and no voltage sag. Reaches 19 mph with confidence across varied terrain. | 8/10 Delivers 19 mph standard with available 25 mph LSV package. Lithium battery provides 40-50 miles of range with good torque. | Evolution Forester 4 Plus |
| Build Quality & Durability | 10/10 Club Car's rust-proof aluminum frame is the industry gold standard. Combined with heavy-duty lifted suspension, it's built to last decades. | 7/10 Well-built for a budget lifted cart with quality components. Solid construction but can't match Club Car's aluminum frame longevity. | Club Car Onward HP Lithium |
| Off-Road Capability | 8/10 Factory lift with bigger wheels and tires, increased ground clearance, and beefier suspension tuned for varied terrain driving. | 8/10 Factory-lifted platform with off-road tires, increased ground clearance, and suspension designed for trails and rough terrain. | Tie |
| Features & Technology | 7/10 Premium headlights, quality controls, and Club Car's refined interface. Additional features available but add to the already premium price. | 9/10 Standard digital dash, Bluetooth speakers, LED lighting, USB ports, and 25 mph capability — all included at the base $6,995 price. | Evolution Forester 4 Plus |
| Value & Pricing | 4/10 Dealer-quote pricing typically puts the Onward HP Lithium well above $15,000. The premium buys aluminum frame and brand prestige. | 10/10 At $6,995 for a lifted lithium 4-passenger cart with modern features, the Forester 4 Plus represents extraordinary value. | Evolution Forester 4 Plus |
| Customization & Accessories | 10/10 The industry's largest aftermarket ecosystem with virtually unlimited options for every possible customization. | 7/10 Good and growing accessory catalog with lift kits, enclosures, and custom parts, but the ecosystem is still developing. | Club Car Onward HP Lithium |
| Brand & Resale Value | 10/10 Club Car is the gold standard for golf cart brand recognition and resale value. HP models hold their value exceptionally well. | 6/10 Evolution is building recognition but resale data is still developing. Budget carts typically depreciate faster than premium brands. | Club Car Onward HP Lithium |
Performance & Power
Evolution Forester 4 PlusLithium-ion power with consistent performance and no voltage sag. Reaches 19 mph with confidence across varied terrain.
Delivers 19 mph standard with available 25 mph LSV package. Lithium battery provides 40-50 miles of range with good torque.
Build Quality & Durability
Club Car Onward HP LithiumClub Car's rust-proof aluminum frame is the industry gold standard. Combined with heavy-duty lifted suspension, it's built to last decades.
Well-built for a budget lifted cart with quality components. Solid construction but can't match Club Car's aluminum frame longevity.
Off-Road Capability
TieFactory lift with bigger wheels and tires, increased ground clearance, and beefier suspension tuned for varied terrain driving.
Factory-lifted platform with off-road tires, increased ground clearance, and suspension designed for trails and rough terrain.
Features & Technology
Evolution Forester 4 PlusPremium headlights, quality controls, and Club Car's refined interface. Additional features available but add to the already premium price.
Standard digital dash, Bluetooth speakers, LED lighting, USB ports, and 25 mph capability — all included at the base $6,995 price.
Value & Pricing
Evolution Forester 4 PlusDealer-quote pricing typically puts the Onward HP Lithium well above $15,000. The premium buys aluminum frame and brand prestige.
At $6,995 for a lifted lithium 4-passenger cart with modern features, the Forester 4 Plus represents extraordinary value.
Customization & Accessories
Club Car Onward HP LithiumThe industry's largest aftermarket ecosystem with virtually unlimited options for every possible customization.
Good and growing accessory catalog with lift kits, enclosures, and custom parts, but the ecosystem is still developing.
Brand & Resale Value
Club Car Onward HP LithiumClub Car is the gold standard for golf cart brand recognition and resale value. HP models hold their value exceptionally well.
Evolution is building recognition but resale data is still developing. Budget carts typically depreciate faster than premium brands.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
Onward HP Lithium
Choose if you...
- 1Club Car's aluminum frame longevity is worth the premium to you
- 2You want the industry's best resale value and brand recognition
- 3Endless aftermarket customization options are important
- 4You view this as a long-term investment lasting 15-20+ years
Forester 4 Plus
Choose if you...
- 1Saving potentially $8,000+ while getting a capable lifted cart is the priority
- 2You want 25 mph speed and modern features included at base price
- 3Budget matters and you'd rather invest the savings elsewhere
- 4You're comfortable with a newer brand offering solid warranty coverage
Similar Models to Consider
Other models from each brand that might fit your needs
Related Comparisons
Explore more comparisons between these brands and models
Onward HP Lithium vs Forester 4 Plus FAQs
Common questions about these two models
Is the Club Car really worth potentially double the Evolution's price?
Which lifted cart is better for actual off-road use?
Can I make the Evolution Forester street legal?
Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?
Get free quotes from local Club Car and Evolution dealers near you.
Stay Updated with Golf Cart News
Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.