CushmanShuttle 6vsStar EVCapella 4+2
Complete head-to-head comparison. Which model is right for you?
Overall Winner: Tie
These 6-passenger carts cater to entirely different buyers. The Cushman Shuttle 6 is a commercial workhorse built for resorts, campuses, and fleet operations where durability and passenger hauling capacity matter most. The Star Capella 4+2 is a personal-use vehicle with modern styling, available LSV speed, and a more refined ownership experience. Commercial buyers choose the Cushman; personal and community buyers choose the Star.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | Cushman Shuttle 6 | Star EV Capella 4+2 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance & Power | 7/10 The Shuttle 6 delivers 19 mph with ELiTE Lithium or gas powertrains. Adequate torque for carrying a full load of six on flat to moderate terrain. | 8/10 The Capella 4+2 offers 19.5 mph standard with an optional 25 mph LSV package. The 5kW AC motor provides strong torque and smooth power delivery. | Star EV Capella 4+2 |
| Build Quality & Durability | 9/10 Commercial-grade construction engineered for thousands of hours of fleet service. Heavy-duty frame, hydraulic disc brakes, and industrial-strength components. | 7/10 Well-built personal vehicle with quality frame and components, but not designed for the punishing daily demands of commercial fleet operations. | Cushman Shuttle 6 |
| Comfort & Ride Quality | 6/10 Functional bench seating for six with a utility-focused firm ride. Comfort is secondary to passenger capacity and durability. | 8/10 Comfortable seating with independent front suspension, refined ride quality, and ergonomic design focused on passenger enjoyment. | Star EV Capella 4+2 |
| Features & Technology | 6/10 Functional headlights, taillights, and commercial-grade essentials. No-frills approach focused on reliability over tech features. | 8/10 Digital instrument cluster, LED lighting, turn signals, USB charging, and available premium audio. Modern features for personal enjoyment. | Star EV Capella 4+2 |
| Value & Pricing | 6/10 Dealer-quote pricing typically reflects commercial-grade premiums. Fleet volume discounts may apply but individual buyers pay more. | 8/10 Competitive pricing for a feature-rich 6-passenger personal vehicle with modern technology and LSV capability included. | Star EV Capella 4+2 |
| Customization & Accessories | 7/10 Fleet and commercial accessory options available. Custom configurations for specific commercial applications. | 8/10 Multiple trim levels, color options, lift kits, and a growing aftermarket accessory catalog for personal customization. | Star EV Capella 4+2 |
| Brand & Dealer Support | 9/10 Cushman's 120+ year commercial vehicle heritage with dedicated fleet service teams and Textron's extensive support network. | 7/10 Star EV (Garia brand) has a solid dealer network that's grown significantly, though not as extensive as Textron's commercial channels. | Cushman Shuttle 6 |
Performance & Power
Star EV Capella 4+2The Shuttle 6 delivers 19 mph with ELiTE Lithium or gas powertrains. Adequate torque for carrying a full load of six on flat to moderate terrain.
The Capella 4+2 offers 19.5 mph standard with an optional 25 mph LSV package. The 5kW AC motor provides strong torque and smooth power delivery.
Build Quality & Durability
Cushman Shuttle 6Commercial-grade construction engineered for thousands of hours of fleet service. Heavy-duty frame, hydraulic disc brakes, and industrial-strength components.
Well-built personal vehicle with quality frame and components, but not designed for the punishing daily demands of commercial fleet operations.
Comfort & Ride Quality
Star EV Capella 4+2Functional bench seating for six with a utility-focused firm ride. Comfort is secondary to passenger capacity and durability.
Comfortable seating with independent front suspension, refined ride quality, and ergonomic design focused on passenger enjoyment.
Features & Technology
Star EV Capella 4+2Functional headlights, taillights, and commercial-grade essentials. No-frills approach focused on reliability over tech features.
Digital instrument cluster, LED lighting, turn signals, USB charging, and available premium audio. Modern features for personal enjoyment.
Value & Pricing
Star EV Capella 4+2Dealer-quote pricing typically reflects commercial-grade premiums. Fleet volume discounts may apply but individual buyers pay more.
Competitive pricing for a feature-rich 6-passenger personal vehicle with modern technology and LSV capability included.
Customization & Accessories
Star EV Capella 4+2Fleet and commercial accessory options available. Custom configurations for specific commercial applications.
Multiple trim levels, color options, lift kits, and a growing aftermarket accessory catalog for personal customization.
Brand & Dealer Support
Cushman Shuttle 6Cushman's 120+ year commercial vehicle heritage with dedicated fleet service teams and Textron's extensive support network.
Star EV (Garia brand) has a solid dealer network that's grown significantly, though not as extensive as Textron's commercial channels.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
Shuttle 6
Choose if you...
- 1You're buying for a resort, campus, or commercial shuttle operation
- 2Heavy daily use demands commercial-grade durability
- 3You need gas power option for unlimited range in fleet operations
- 4Cushman's commercial dealer support network serves your area
Capella 4+2
Choose if you...
- 1This is a personal vehicle for neighborhood or community use
- 2You want 25 mph LSV capability for street-legal driving
- 3Comfort, styling, and modern features matter to you
- 4You prefer better value pricing for a feature-rich personal cart
Similar Models to Consider
Other models from each brand that might fit your needs
Related Comparisons
Explore more comparisons between these brands and models
Shuttle 6 vs Capella 4+2 FAQs
Common questions about these two models
Which is better for a resort or hotel?
Can the Star Capella 4+2 be used commercially?
What does the 4+2 seating configuration mean?
Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?
Get free quotes from local Cushman and Star EV dealers near you.
Stay Updated with Golf Cart News
Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.