EvolutionClassic 4 PlusvsICON EVi40
Complete head-to-head comparison. Which model is right for you?
Overall Winner: ICON EV i40
ICON i40 edges out the Evolution Classic 4 Plus with its industry-leading 10-year battery warranty, four-wheel disc brakes, and higher top speed. Evolution counters with a significantly lower price point at nearly half the cost. Both deliver excellent value - your budget determines the winner.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | Evolution Classic 4 Plus | ICON EV i40 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price & Value | 10/10 Starts at $6,795 - nearly half the price of competitors. Exceptional entry point for lithium 4-seaters. | 6/10 Starts at $12,999. More expensive but includes premium features and warranty. | Evolution Classic 4 Plus |
| Battery Warranty | 6/10 Standard lithium battery with 2-year limited warranty coverage. | 10/10 51V/105Ah ECO Lithium with industry-leading 10-year battery warranty. | ICON EV i40 |
| Technology & Display | 8/10 9-inch touchscreen entertainment system, backup camera, Bluetooth, LED lighting. | 9/10 10.1" IP67-rated multimedia touchscreen, backup camera, Bluetooth, carbon fiber dash. | Tie |
| Braking System | 7/10 Standard braking system adequate for normal use. | 10/10 Four-wheel disc brakes with electromagnetic parking brake. Industry-leading stopping power. | ICON EV i40 |
| Top Speed & LSV | 7/10 19 mph standard, 25 mph available with LSV package upgrade. | 9/10 25 mph standard, street-legal ready out of the box. | ICON EV i40 |
| Vehicle Warranty | 6/10 2-year limited warranty. Standard coverage for the price point. | 8/10 3-year vehicle warranty plus 10-year battery. Comprehensive protection. | ICON EV i40 |
| Brand Momentum | 7/10 Growing brand with good reputation. Strong dealer presence in key markets. | 9/10 Fastest-growing golf cart brand with aggressive marketing and strong dealer network. | ICON EV i40 |
| Feature Set | 8/10 Touchscreen, backup camera, Bluetooth, LED lights, plush seating, cup holders, storage. | 8/10 Touchscreen, backup camera, Bluetooth, LED lights, locking compartments, carbon fiber dash. | Tie |
Price & Value
Evolution Classic 4 PlusStarts at $6,795 - nearly half the price of competitors. Exceptional entry point for lithium 4-seaters.
Starts at $12,999. More expensive but includes premium features and warranty.
Battery Warranty
ICON EV i40Standard lithium battery with 2-year limited warranty coverage.
51V/105Ah ECO Lithium with industry-leading 10-year battery warranty.
Technology & Display
Tie9-inch touchscreen entertainment system, backup camera, Bluetooth, LED lighting.
10.1" IP67-rated multimedia touchscreen, backup camera, Bluetooth, carbon fiber dash.
Braking System
ICON EV i40Standard braking system adequate for normal use.
Four-wheel disc brakes with electromagnetic parking brake. Industry-leading stopping power.
Top Speed & LSV
ICON EV i4019 mph standard, 25 mph available with LSV package upgrade.
25 mph standard, street-legal ready out of the box.
Vehicle Warranty
ICON EV i402-year limited warranty. Standard coverage for the price point.
3-year vehicle warranty plus 10-year battery. Comprehensive protection.
Brand Momentum
ICON EV i40Growing brand with good reputation. Strong dealer presence in key markets.
Fastest-growing golf cart brand with aggressive marketing and strong dealer network.
Feature Set
TieTouchscreen, backup camera, Bluetooth, LED lights, plush seating, cup holders, storage.
Touchscreen, backup camera, Bluetooth, LED lights, locking compartments, carbon fiber dash.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
Classic 4 Plus
Choose if you...
- 1Budget is your primary concern
- 2You want a capable 4-seater under $7,000
- 3Good technology at a low price matters
- 4You don't need a 10-year battery warranty
- 5You're okay upgrading for LSV speed
i40
Choose if you...
- 1Battery warranty is your top priority (10 years)
- 2Four-wheel disc brakes are important to you
- 3You want 25 mph street-legal speed standard
- 4Longer vehicle warranty matters (3 years)
- 5You prefer stronger brand and dealer support
Similar Models to Consider
Other models from each brand that might fit your needs
Related Comparisons
Explore more comparisons between these brands and models
Classic 4 Plus vs i40 FAQs
Common questions about these two models
Why is Evolution so much cheaper than ICON?
Which has better technology?
Which is better for the money?
Which has better brakes?
Can both be street-legal?
Which brand is more reliable?
Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?
Get free quotes from local Evolution and ICON EV dealers near you.
Stay Updated with Golf Cart News
Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.