E-Z-GOLibertyvsStar EVCapella 4
Complete head-to-head comparison. Which model is right for you?
Overall Winner: E-Z-GO Liberty
The E-Z-GO Liberty wins on overall value with its proven Samsung SDI lithium technology, 50-mile range, lower price, and established dealer network. The Star Capella 4 counters with 4-wheel hydraulic brakes and multiple lithium battery tiers, but its $2,600 premium is hard to justify.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | E-Z-GO Liberty | Star EV Capella 4 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance | 8/10 Very close. The Liberty delivers proven 50-mile range from Samsung SDI lithium. | 8/10 The Capella 4's 5kW motor and 350A controller produce slightly more top speed at 19. 5 mph. | Tie |
| Build Quality | 8/10 E-Z-GO's decades of manufacturing expertise and quality control give the Liberty a slight edge over the Capella 4's welded steel frame construction. | 7/10 E-Z-GO's decades of manufacturing expertise and quality control give the Liberty a slight edge over the Capella 4's welded steel frame construction. | E-Z-GO Liberty |
| Comfort & Features | 7/10 The Capella 4 includes comprehensive LED lighting with daytime running lights, integrated turn signals, and emergency flashers as standard — a more complete package out of the box. | 8/10 The Capella 4 includes comprehensive LED lighting with daytime running lights, integrated turn signals, and emergency flashers as standard — a more complete package out of the box. | Star EV Capella 4 |
| Value for Money | 8/10 At $2,600 less with a proven 50-mile range and established brand support, the Liberty offers significantly better value for most buyers. | 6/10 At $2,600 less with a proven 50-mile range and established brand support, the Liberty offers significantly better value for most buyers. | E-Z-GO Liberty |
| Safety & Braking | 7/10 The Capella 4's 4-wheel hydraulic brakes are a standout safety feature, providing superior stopping power compared to the Liberty's standard braking system. | 9/10 The Capella 4's 4-wheel hydraulic brakes are a standout safety feature, providing superior stopping power compared to the Liberty's standard braking system. | Star EV Capella 4 |
| Battery Options | 7/10 The Capella 4 offers lead-acid plus three Star Smart Lithium tiers (105Ah, 160Ah, 210Ah), giving buyers far more flexibility than the Liberty's single ELiTE Lithium option. | 9/10 The Capella 4 offers lead-acid plus three Star Smart Lithium tiers (105Ah, 160Ah, 210Ah), giving buyers far more flexibility than the Liberty's single ELiTE Lithium option. | Star EV Capella 4 |
| Brand & Dealer Support | 9/10 E-Z-GO's extensive, decades-old dealer network makes service, parts, and warranty support significantly more accessible than Star EV's growing infrastructure. | 6/10 E-Z-GO's extensive, decades-old dealer network makes service, parts, and warranty support significantly more accessible than Star EV's growing infrastructure. | E-Z-GO Liberty |
Performance
TieVery close. The Liberty delivers proven 50-mile range from Samsung SDI lithium.
The Capella 4's 5kW motor and 350A controller produce slightly more top speed at 19. 5 mph.
Build Quality
E-Z-GO LibertyE-Z-GO's decades of manufacturing expertise and quality control give the Liberty a slight edge over the Capella 4's welded steel frame construction.
E-Z-GO's decades of manufacturing expertise and quality control give the Liberty a slight edge over the Capella 4's welded steel frame construction.
Comfort & Features
Star EV Capella 4The Capella 4 includes comprehensive LED lighting with daytime running lights, integrated turn signals, and emergency flashers as standard — a more complete package out of the box.
The Capella 4 includes comprehensive LED lighting with daytime running lights, integrated turn signals, and emergency flashers as standard — a more complete package out of the box.
Value for Money
E-Z-GO LibertyAt $2,600 less with a proven 50-mile range and established brand support, the Liberty offers significantly better value for most buyers.
At $2,600 less with a proven 50-mile range and established brand support, the Liberty offers significantly better value for most buyers.
Safety & Braking
Star EV Capella 4The Capella 4's 4-wheel hydraulic brakes are a standout safety feature, providing superior stopping power compared to the Liberty's standard braking system.
The Capella 4's 4-wheel hydraulic brakes are a standout safety feature, providing superior stopping power compared to the Liberty's standard braking system.
Battery Options
Star EV Capella 4The Capella 4 offers lead-acid plus three Star Smart Lithium tiers (105Ah, 160Ah, 210Ah), giving buyers far more flexibility than the Liberty's single ELiTE Lithium option.
The Capella 4 offers lead-acid plus three Star Smart Lithium tiers (105Ah, 160Ah, 210Ah), giving buyers far more flexibility than the Liberty's single ELiTE Lithium option.
Brand & Dealer Support
E-Z-GO LibertyE-Z-GO's extensive, decades-old dealer network makes service, parts, and warranty support significantly more accessible than Star EV's growing infrastructure.
E-Z-GO's extensive, decades-old dealer network makes service, parts, and warranty support significantly more accessible than Star EV's growing infrastructure.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
Liberty
Choose if you...
- 1Proven 50-mile ELiTE Lithium range is important
- 2E-Z-GO's dealer network and brand trust matter
- 3You want to save $2,600 on a premium 4-seater
- 4Samsung SDI battery technology appeals to you
Capella 4
Choose if you...
- 14-wheel hydraulic brakes are a must-have safety feature
- 2You want multiple lithium battery capacity options (105-210Ah)
- 3Comprehensive LED lighting and daytime running lights matter
- 4You value the flexibility to choose your battery capacity
Similar Models to Consider
Other models from each brand that might fit your needs
Related Comparisons
Explore more comparisons between these brands and models
Liberty vs Capella 4 FAQs
Common questions about these two models
Is the Star Capella 4 worth $2,600 more than the E-Z-GO Liberty?
Which has a better lithium battery system?
Which brand is more established?
Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?
Get free quotes from local E-Z-GO and Star EV dealers near you.
Stay Updated with Golf Cart News
Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.