Star EVSirius 4vsEvolutionClassic 4 Plus
Complete head-to-head comparison. Which model is right for you?
Overall Winner: Evolution Classic 4 Plus
Evolution Classic 4 Plus wins with its dramatically lower price at nearly half the cost of Star Sirius 4. Star counters with a longer warranty, more established reputation, and hydraulic brakes. If budget is primary, Evolution wins decisively. If warranty and track record matter, Star has the edge.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | Star EV Sirius 4 | Evolution Classic 4 Plus | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price & Value | 5/10 Starts at $13,499. Premium pricing for a value brand with extensive features. | 10/10 Starts at $6,795 - nearly half the price. Exceptional entry point for a feature-rich 4-seater. | Evolution Classic 4 Plus |
| Warranty Coverage | 9/10 4-year limited warranty with 2-year bumper-to-bumper. Among the longest in the value segment. | 6/10 2-year limited warranty. Standard coverage for the price point. | Star EV Sirius 4 |
| Braking System | 9/10 4-wheel hydraulic brakes with front disc, rear drum. Foot-activated parking brake. | 7/10 Standard braking system adequate for normal use. | Star EV Sirius 4 |
| Technology & Display | 7/10 Full-color display with speedometer, odometer, battery indicator. Functional and clear. | 9/10 9-inch touchscreen entertainment system, backup camera, Bluetooth connectivity. | Evolution Classic 4 Plus |
| Brand Establishment | 9/10 20+ years in the industry. Proven track record and established dealer network. | 7/10 Founded 2016. Growing reputation but still proving long-term reliability. | Star EV Sirius 4 |
| Battery Options | 9/10 Trojan lead-acid or Star Smart Lithium (105Ah, 160Ah, 210Ah options). | 7/10 Lithium electric only. No lead-acid option for lower upfront cost. | Star EV Sirius 4 |
| Build Features | 8/10 Electronic locking trunk, folding tinted windshield, adjustable seat backs, USB/12V outlets. | 7/10 Plush seating, storage compartments, LED lighting, cup holders. | Star EV Sirius 4 |
| Motor & Performance | 8/10 5kW AC motor with thermal protection. 48V 450A controller. Proven performance. | 7/10 Lithium-ion powered system. Good performance for the price. | Star EV Sirius 4 |
Price & Value
Evolution Classic 4 PlusStarts at $13,499. Premium pricing for a value brand with extensive features.
Starts at $6,795 - nearly half the price. Exceptional entry point for a feature-rich 4-seater.
Warranty Coverage
Star EV Sirius 44-year limited warranty with 2-year bumper-to-bumper. Among the longest in the value segment.
2-year limited warranty. Standard coverage for the price point.
Braking System
Star EV Sirius 44-wheel hydraulic brakes with front disc, rear drum. Foot-activated parking brake.
Standard braking system adequate for normal use.
Technology & Display
Evolution Classic 4 PlusFull-color display with speedometer, odometer, battery indicator. Functional and clear.
9-inch touchscreen entertainment system, backup camera, Bluetooth connectivity.
Brand Establishment
Star EV Sirius 420+ years in the industry. Proven track record and established dealer network.
Founded 2016. Growing reputation but still proving long-term reliability.
Battery Options
Star EV Sirius 4Trojan lead-acid or Star Smart Lithium (105Ah, 160Ah, 210Ah options).
Lithium electric only. No lead-acid option for lower upfront cost.
Build Features
Star EV Sirius 4Electronic locking trunk, folding tinted windshield, adjustable seat backs, USB/12V outlets.
Plush seating, storage compartments, LED lighting, cup holders.
Motor & Performance
Star EV Sirius 45kW AC motor with thermal protection. 48V 450A controller. Proven performance.
Lithium-ion powered system. Good performance for the price.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
Sirius 4
Choose if you...
- 1Warranty length is a top priority (4 years)
- 2You want proven brand reliability (20+ years)
- 3Superior braking with hydraulic system matters
- 4You want lead-acid option for lower upfront cost
- 5Multiple lithium capacity options appeal to you
Classic 4 Plus
Choose if you...
- 1Budget is your primary concern (save ~$7,000)
- 2You want a touchscreen entertainment system
- 3Modern tech features matter more than warranty
- 4You want the lowest price for a lithium 4-seater
- 5Entry-level pricing is more important than extras
Similar Models to Consider
Other models from each brand that might fit your needs
Related Comparisons
Explore more comparisons between these brands and models
Sirius 4 vs Classic 4 Plus FAQs
Common questions about these two models
Why is Star Sirius 4 so much more expensive?
Which has better warranty coverage?
Which is better for the money?
Which brand is more reliable?
Which has better brakes?
Can I get a lead-acid battery option?
Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?
Get free quotes from local Star EV and Evolution dealers near you.
Stay Updated with Golf Cart News
Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.