EvolutionForester 4 PlusvsICON EVi40L
Complete head-to-head comparison. Which model is right for you?
Overall Winner: Tie
Evolution Forester 4 Plus is the budget champion at half the price of the ICON i40L, offering genuine off-road capability with elevated chassis and all-terrain tires. ICON i40L wins on technology, braking, battery warranty, and overall build quality. Choose Evolution for maximum value, or ICON for maximum features and long-term confidence.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | Evolution Forester 4 Plus | ICON EV i40L | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price & Value | 10/10 Starts at $6,995 - roughly half the ICON's price. Incredible value for a lifted, off-road capable 4-seater. | 5/10 Starts at $13,999. More features and better build quality but at a significant price premium. | Evolution Forester 4 Plus |
| Off-Road Capability | 8/10 Elevated chassis design with off-road silent tires. Purpose-built for all-terrain driving. | 8/10 Lifted suspension with enhanced ground clearance. Capable off-road platform. | Tie |
| Technology & Features | 6/10 LSV package available with basic features. Less tech-focused than ICON. | 9/10 10-inch multimedia touchscreen, backup camera, Bluetooth, carbon fiber dash, full LED package. | ICON EV i40L |
| Braking System | 6/10 Standard braking system suitable for normal driving conditions. | 9/10 Four-wheel disc brakes with electromagnetic parking brake. Premium stopping power. | ICON EV i40L |
| Battery & Warranty | 6/10 Lithium-ion battery with 2-year limited warranty. Adequate but basic coverage. | 10/10 51V/105Ah ECO Lithium with 3-year vehicle warranty and 10-year battery warranty. | ICON EV i40L |
| Build Quality | 6/10 Budget-focused construction with rugged body design. Suitable for its price point. | 8/10 Higher-quality materials and finish. More refined construction and premium feel. | ICON EV i40L |
| Suspension & Ride | 7/10 Elevated chassis with enhanced rear axle. Capable but basic suspension. | 8/10 MacPherson-style independent front suspension with coil-over shocks and rear stabilizing bar. | ICON EV i40L |
Price & Value
Evolution Forester 4 PlusStarts at $6,995 - roughly half the ICON's price. Incredible value for a lifted, off-road capable 4-seater.
Starts at $13,999. More features and better build quality but at a significant price premium.
Off-Road Capability
TieElevated chassis design with off-road silent tires. Purpose-built for all-terrain driving.
Lifted suspension with enhanced ground clearance. Capable off-road platform.
Technology & Features
ICON EV i40LLSV package available with basic features. Less tech-focused than ICON.
10-inch multimedia touchscreen, backup camera, Bluetooth, carbon fiber dash, full LED package.
Braking System
ICON EV i40LStandard braking system suitable for normal driving conditions.
Four-wheel disc brakes with electromagnetic parking brake. Premium stopping power.
Battery & Warranty
ICON EV i40LLithium-ion battery with 2-year limited warranty. Adequate but basic coverage.
51V/105Ah ECO Lithium with 3-year vehicle warranty and 10-year battery warranty.
Build Quality
ICON EV i40LBudget-focused construction with rugged body design. Suitable for its price point.
Higher-quality materials and finish. More refined construction and premium feel.
Suspension & Ride
ICON EV i40LElevated chassis with enhanced rear axle. Capable but basic suspension.
MacPherson-style independent front suspension with coil-over shocks and rear stabilizing bar.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
Forester 4 Plus
Choose if you...
- 1Budget is your top priority (save $7,000)
- 2You want a lifted off-road cart at the lowest price
- 3All-terrain tires are included at this price
- 4You don't need premium technology features
- 5You plan to use the cart for 3-5 years
i40L
Choose if you...
- 1Technology and features matter (touchscreen, backup camera)
- 2Four-wheel disc brakes are important for safety
- 3A 10-year battery warranty gives you long-term confidence
- 4Independent front suspension for a smoother ride
- 5You want a premium build quality and materials
Similar Models to Consider
Other models from each brand that might fit your needs
Related Comparisons
Explore more comparisons between these brands and models
Forester 4 Plus vs i40L FAQs
Common questions about these two models
Is the Evolution Forester 4 Plus really half the price?
Which is better off-road?
Is the ICON i40L worth double the price?
Which has the better warranty?
Which rides smoother?
Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?
Get free quotes from local Evolution and ICON EV dealers near you.
Stay Updated with Golf Cart News
Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.