GEMe2vsICONi20
Complete head-to-head comparison. Which model is right for you?
Overall Winner: ICON i20
The ICON i20 wins this comparison for most buyers by offering comparable 25 mph LSV capability with a richer feature set at $3,241 less than the GEM e2. ICON's rapidly-growing dealer network and strong brand reputation further strengthen its position. The GEM e2 still has advantages in FMVSS certification rigor and Polaris corporate backing, making it the choice for buyers who prioritize factory LSV pedigree above all else — but for most personal buyers, the ICON delivers more value.
Quick Comparison
Key differences at a glance
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Detailed comparison across all important factors
| Category | GEM e2 | ICON i20 | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Performance & Power | 7/10 Reaches 25 mph with up to 45 miles of lithium range. Adequate acceleration for a 2-passenger LSV with smooth power delivery. | 8/10 Also delivers 25 mph with 40-60 miles of lithium range. Strong acceleration from ICON's proven electric drivetrain with excellent torque. | ICON i20 |
| Safety & Street Legality | 10/10 Full FMVSS-certified LSV with automotive glass windshield, 3-point seatbelts, DOT tires, and comprehensive safety engineering from Polaris. | 8/10 LSV-capable with turn signals, mirrors, seatbelts, and DOT tires. Meets requirements for street-legal operation in most jurisdictions. | GEM e2 |
| Features & Technology | 8/10 7-inch touchscreen, Bluetooth connectivity, onboard diagnostics, USB charging, and full LED lighting. Premium tech package from Polaris. | 8/10 Digital display, LED lighting, Bluetooth speakers, USB charging, and ICON's well-designed control interface. Strong standard feature set. | Tie |
| Comfort & Ride Quality | 8/10 Automotive-style seating with 3-point belts, independent front suspension, and enclosed cabin options for all-weather comfort. | 7/10 Comfortable seating with good suspension and open-air design. Enjoyable ride quality on paved and community roads. | GEM e2 |
| Value & Pricing | 6/10 At $15,240, the GEM e2 carries a premium for its FMVSS pedigree and Polaris backing. It's a significant investment for a 2-passenger vehicle. | 9/10 At $11,999, the ICON i20 saves $3,241 while delivering comparable performance, range, and features. Exceptional value for a 2-seat LSV. | ICON i20 |
| Customization & Accessories | 6/10 GEM offers factory options like enclosed cabs and cargo accessories, but the aftermarket ecosystem is smaller and more specialized. | 8/10 ICON has a strong and growing accessory catalog with lift kits, custom wheels, enclosures, and a vibrant aftermarket community. | ICON i20 |
| Brand & Dealer Support | 8/10 GEM is backed by Polaris — a Fortune 500 powersports company with established dealer support and corporate stability. | 8/10 ICON has rapidly built one of the largest dealer networks in the alternative golf cart space with strong customer satisfaction and growing brand loyalty. | Tie |
Performance & Power
ICON i20Reaches 25 mph with up to 45 miles of lithium range. Adequate acceleration for a 2-passenger LSV with smooth power delivery.
Also delivers 25 mph with 40-60 miles of lithium range. Strong acceleration from ICON's proven electric drivetrain with excellent torque.
Safety & Street Legality
GEM e2Full FMVSS-certified LSV with automotive glass windshield, 3-point seatbelts, DOT tires, and comprehensive safety engineering from Polaris.
LSV-capable with turn signals, mirrors, seatbelts, and DOT tires. Meets requirements for street-legal operation in most jurisdictions.
Features & Technology
Tie7-inch touchscreen, Bluetooth connectivity, onboard diagnostics, USB charging, and full LED lighting. Premium tech package from Polaris.
Digital display, LED lighting, Bluetooth speakers, USB charging, and ICON's well-designed control interface. Strong standard feature set.
Comfort & Ride Quality
GEM e2Automotive-style seating with 3-point belts, independent front suspension, and enclosed cabin options for all-weather comfort.
Comfortable seating with good suspension and open-air design. Enjoyable ride quality on paved and community roads.
Value & Pricing
ICON i20At $15,240, the GEM e2 carries a premium for its FMVSS pedigree and Polaris backing. It's a significant investment for a 2-passenger vehicle.
At $11,999, the ICON i20 saves $3,241 while delivering comparable performance, range, and features. Exceptional value for a 2-seat LSV.
Customization & Accessories
ICON i20GEM offers factory options like enclosed cabs and cargo accessories, but the aftermarket ecosystem is smaller and more specialized.
ICON has a strong and growing accessory catalog with lift kits, custom wheels, enclosures, and a vibrant aftermarket community.
Brand & Dealer Support
TieGEM is backed by Polaris — a Fortune 500 powersports company with established dealer support and corporate stability.
ICON has rapidly built one of the largest dealer networks in the alternative golf cart space with strong customer satisfaction and growing brand loyalty.
Which Should You Buy?
Recommendations based on your priorities
e2
Choose if you...
- 1Factory FMVSS certification and automotive-grade safety are non-negotiable
- 2You want an automotive glass windshield for all-weather driving
- 3Polaris corporate backing and warranty support give you confidence
- 4You plan to add an enclosed cabin for year-round use
i20
Choose if you...
- 1Saving $3,241 on a comparable 2-passenger LSV is appealing
- 2You want more aftermarket customization options
- 3ICON's larger dealer network is accessible in your area
- 4Better range (40-60 miles vs 45 miles) matters for your driving needs
Similar Models to Consider
Other models from each brand that might fit your needs
Related Comparisons
Explore more comparisons between these brands and models
e2 vs i20 FAQs
Common questions about these two models
Are both carts equally street legal?
Which 2-passenger LSV has better range?
Is GEM or ICON a better long-term brand?
Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?
Get free quotes from local GEM and ICON dealers near you.
Stay Updated with Golf Cart News
Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.