Brand Comparison

Club CarvsStar EV

Complete comparison of two popular golf cart brands. Which is right for you?

Overall Winner: Club Car

Club Car wins for buyers prioritizing rust-proof aluminum construction, superior resale value, and Big 3 reliability. Star EV wins for budget-conscious buyers who want proven value-brand reliability (20+ years), lower prices, and excellent customization options. The $1,500-3,000 price difference is significant.

Quick Comparison

Key differences at a glance

Club CarWINNER

Star EV

Price Range

$9,475 - $24,334

$7,995 - $14,995

Frame Material

Aluminum (AlumiCore™)

Steel

Warranty

2 years

Category-by-Category Breakdown

Detailed comparison across all important factors

Category	Club Car	Star EV	Winner
Build Quality & Frame	10/10 Aircraft-grade aluminum AlumiCore™ frame. Completely rust-proof, lighter weight, 20+ year lifespan.	7/10 Steel frame construction. Good quality for value segment but can rust over time.	Club Car
Brand Reputation & Track Record	10/10 65+ years as the premium golf cart leader. Unmatched Big 3 reputation.	7/10 20+ years in business since 2002. Solid track record as established value brand.	Club Car
Price & Value	6/10 Premium pricing starting at $9,475. You pay for aluminum frame and brand reputation.	9/10 Value-focused starting around $7,995. Significant savings over Club Car.	Tie
Customization Options	7/10 Good model variety but more standardized Big 3 configurations.	9/10 Known for customization flexibility. Multiple lines with various configurations.	Tie
Resale Value	10/10 Industry-leading resale value. Aluminum frame maintains structural integrity for decades.	6/10 Decent resale for value brand. Less brand recognition affects long-term values.	Club Car
Dealer Network	10/10 Extensive nationwide network built over 65+ years. Service available anywhere.	7/10 Good dealer network built over 20+ years. Solid but not Big 3 level coverage.	Club Car
Performance	9/10 Superior hill-climbing due to lighter aluminum frame. Excellent power-to-weight ratio.	7/10 Good performance with street-legal speeds. Adequate for most uses.	Club Car
Features & Technology	8/10 Monsoon Canopy, LED lighting, three drive modes on HP models. Quality features.	8/10 Digital displays, LED lighting, Bluetooth available. Good features for value brand.	Tie

Build Quality & Frame

Club Car

Club Car10/10

Aircraft-grade aluminum AlumiCore™ frame. Completely rust-proof, lighter weight, 20+ year lifespan.

Star EV7/10

Steel frame construction. Good quality for value segment but can rust over time.

Brand Reputation & Track Record

Club Car

Club Car10/10

65+ years as the premium golf cart leader. Unmatched Big 3 reputation.

Star EV7/10

20+ years in business since 2002. Solid track record as established value brand.

Price & Value

Tie

Club Car6/10

Premium pricing starting at $9,475. You pay for aluminum frame and brand reputation.

Star EV9/10

Value-focused starting around $7,995. Significant savings over Club Car.

Customization Options

Tie

Club Car7/10

Good model variety but more standardized Big 3 configurations.

Star EV9/10

Known for customization flexibility. Multiple lines with various configurations.

Resale Value

Club Car

Club Car10/10

Industry-leading resale value. Aluminum frame maintains structural integrity for decades.

Star EV6/10

Decent resale for value brand. Less brand recognition affects long-term values.

Dealer Network

Club Car

Club Car10/10

Extensive nationwide network built over 65+ years. Service available anywhere.

Star EV7/10

Good dealer network built over 20+ years. Solid but not Big 3 level coverage.

Performance

Club Car

Club Car9/10

Superior hill-climbing due to lighter aluminum frame. Excellent power-to-weight ratio.

Star EV7/10

Good performance with street-legal speeds. Adequate for most uses.

Features & Technology

Tie

Club Car8/10

Monsoon Canopy, LED lighting, three drive modes on HP models. Quality features.

Star EV8/10

Digital displays, LED lighting, Bluetooth available. Good features for value brand.

Popular Model Comparisons

Head-to-head matchups of similar models

Club Car Onward 4 Passenger

$10,722

Star EV Sirius 4

$8,995

Seating4 passengers

FrameAluminum

FrameSteel

Warranty2-year vehicle

Warranty-

Key Features-

Key FeaturesLED lights, digital display

Club Car costs $1,727 more but has rust-proof aluminum frame and better resale value.

Club Car Onward HP Li-Ion

$13,120

Star EV Capella 4

$9,995

Seating2-4 passengers

Seating4 passengers

Battery6-year warranty

Battery-

Warranty-

Warranty2-year vehicle

Key FeaturesThree drive modes, aluminum frame

Key FeaturesPremium seating, customization

Club Car costs $3,125 more with aluminum frame and lithium technology.

Which Should You Buy?

Recommendations based on your priorities

Star EV

Best for: Quality & reliability

Choose if you...

1Budget savings are your priority
2Customization options are important
3You live in a dry climate (less rust concern)
420+ year value brand track record is sufficient
5You want more configuration flexibility

View Star EV models

Club Car

Best for: Long-term value & durability

RECOMMENDED

Choose if you...

1You live in a coastal, humid, or snowy climate
2Long-term resale value is a priority
3You want rust-proof aluminum construction
4You need extensive dealer/service network
5You're buying for 15+ years of use

View Club Car models

Other Brand Comparisons

Explore more head-to-head matchups

Advanced EV vs ICON EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

Star EV vs Denago

Head-to-head brand comparison

Evolution vs Denago

Head-to-head brand comparison

Yamaha vs Denago

Head-to-head brand comparison

E-Z-GO vs Denago

Head-to-head brand comparison

Club Car vs E-Z-GO

Aluminum vs steel frame comparison

Yamaha vs Club Car

Warranty vs resale value comparison

Yamaha vs E-Z-GO

Warranty vs budget comparison

ICON EV vs Evolution

Head-to-head brand comparison

Club Car vs ICON EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

E-Z-GO vs Evolution

Head-to-head brand comparison

Star EV vs Evolution

Head-to-head brand comparison

Star EV vs ICON EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

Yamaha vs Star EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

E-Z-GO vs Star EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

Club Car vs Denago

Head-to-head brand comparison

Club Car vs Evolution

Head-to-head brand comparison

E-Z-GO vs ICON EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

Yamaha vs Evolution

Head-to-head brand comparison

Yamaha vs ICON EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

Denago vs ICON EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

Advanced EV vs Evolution Electric Vehicles

Head-to-head brand comparison

Advanced EV vs Club Car

Head-to-head brand comparison

GEM vs Club Car

Head-to-head brand comparison

GEM vs E-Z-GO

Head-to-head brand comparison

Tomberlin vs ICON EV

Head-to-head brand comparison

Cushman vs E-Z-GO

Head-to-head brand comparison

Best Golf Cart Brands

See all 10 top-ranked brands

Club Car vs Star EV FAQs

Common questions about these two brands

Is Club Car worth the extra money over Star EV?

For buyers in humid, coastal, or snowy climates, yes. The aluminum frame eliminates rust concerns and provides better resale value. For buyers in dry climates focused on budget, Star EV's 20+ year track record makes it a reliable choice at lower prices.

Which brand is more reliable?

Both are reliable. Club Car has 65+ years of Big 3 reliability. Star EV has 20+ years as an established value brand. Club Car is safer for brand confidence, but Star EV has proven itself over two decades.

Will Star EV's steel frame last as long as Club Car's aluminum?

In dry climates with proper care, Star EV's steel frame can last many years. In humid, coastal, or snowy environments, Club Car's aluminum frame has a significant advantage as it cannot rust.

Which offers better customization?

Star EV is known for customization flexibility with multiple lines (Sirius, Capella, Cepheus) and various configurations. Club Car offers good variety but Star EV has more options.

Which brand has better resale value?

Club Car has significantly better resale value due to its aluminum frame and Big 3 brand recognition. Star EV has decent value-brand resale but can't match Club Car's long-term value retention.

Which is easier to service?

Club Car has a more extensive dealer network due to its Big 3 status. Star EV has good coverage built over 20+ years but Club Car has the advantage in service accessibility.

Ready to Find Your Golf Cart?

Get free quotes from local Club Car and Star EV dealers near you.

Compare Other Brands

Stay in the loop

Stay Updated with Golf Cart News

Get the latest updates on golf cart services, tips, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox.